|Wednesday, January 14, 2015
You are here: Home » Opinion » Borderline Bayern Blown Away in Berlin by Hummels’ Header, Lose 1:0
  • Follow MunichNOW on

Borderline Bayern Blown Away in Berlin by Hummels’ Header, Lose 1:0 

Sport Commentary from Mark Lovell

Munich (Special to MunichNOW) Bayern Munich ended their season in disappointing fashion with a narrow defeat against Borussia Dortmund in the Cup Final in the German capital Berlin. Saturday’s hard-fought final was decided by man-of-the-match Mats Hummels’ winner in the 64th minute.

The German international defender’s header from a Nuri Sahin cross was hacked away on the line by Bayern defender Dante. Referee Florian Meyer and his assistants were unsure whether the ball had crossed the line and immediately requested a video replay of the incident as per the new guidelines.

The momentous decision took mere seconds to clarify whilst the BVB players wheeled away in celebration. The clear evidence that the ball was well over Manuel Neuer’s line - therefore a legitimate goal - sent the jubilant Dortmund fans into raptures – as well as effervescent coach Jürgen Klopp into a jig on the touchline.

Of course, this isn’t the first time that Neuer, arguably the world’s best goalkeeper, has been embroiled in goal-line controversy. England’s Frank Lampard’s thought he had scored an equaliser at the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, with replays clearly showing that the Three Lions midfielder’s shot was two yards over the line.

Germany’s goalkeeper Manuel Neuer tries to save a shot by England’s Frank Lampard during the 2010 FIFA World Cup round of 16 match between Germany and England at the Free State Stadium in Bloemfontein, South Africa 27 June 2010. Photo: Marcus Brandt dpa

Mats Hummels scores against FC Bayern and wins the match — photo: dpa


The near-save by Dante - but the goal is shown to be good on video replay — photo: dpa

 On that occasion, the goal was not awarded and Germany went on to comfortably win the crunch quarter-final in Bloemfontein. In their infinite wisdom, FIFA have now decided to introduce hi-tech technology at the forthcoming 2014 World Cup in Brazil, following a successful trial at the Confederations Cup.

The “straw that broke the camel’s back” in the Bundesliga was Stefan Kiessling’s ‘ghost goal’ scored for Leverkusen against Hoffenheim in October. “If ever there was one example to be in favour of goal-line technology, then this is the match,” Leverkusen’s sporting director Rudi Völler said after that particular phantom of the Bundesliga.

Following the lead of England’s Premier League (who introduced the popular and pacifying scheme at the beginning of 2013-14) the much-heralded “Made in Germany” video technology was hurried in all across the country to avoid such flashpoints and controversy.

“Vorsprung durch Technik” (Progress Through Technology) it proved - at least from a Dortmund standpoint. Ironically for the Bavarians, they had voted for its introduction in the March vote, so the Record German Champions’ forward-thinking came back to haunt them at a most inopportune time.

However, in the modern mega-rich game with multi-million € salaries and billions “on the line”, it would seem common sense that games are not won or lost by not having video camera equipment. German football’s decision-makers can feel some pride that technology had ultimately ensured that the correct decision was made at such a pivotal moment in the final game of the domestic campaign.

These words were never more true than yesterday - “Progress Through Technology” — photo: dpa


Related Stories:

About the author: Mark Lovell

English (NCTJ) bilingual writer, living and working in Germany for over two decades. Accredited journalist, who travels all around the country taking in the 'Beautiful Game'. A regular pundit on TV (CNN) and worldwide radio (talkSPORT) waxing lyrical about the thriving Bundesliga and Champions League. A commissioned writer for BBC Sport on German football. A gifted linguist including cricket commentary in German for Eurosport. Record run scorer and founder of www.munichcricket.net website. As always I am indebted to my beautiful wife Jana for her support and patience, especially when I am away on my travels, attending to my sporting whims. Follow Mark Lovell on twitter @LovellLowdown or contact via email : henrymarklovell (at) aol.com

One Response to Borderline Bayern Blown Away in Berlin by Hummels’ Header, Lose 1:0

  1. Pingback: Borderline Bayern Blown Away in Berlin by Hummels’ Header, Lose 1:0 | Bundesliga Fanatic

Add a Comment

3 + = eleven